Sustainability-focused product brands face a frustrating paradox. Despite growing consumer interest in ethical and sustainable products, these values fail to translate into purchasing decisions in the mass market. Behavioural science provides a term for this disconnect: the attitude-behaviour gap.
In surveys, consumers consistently express a willingness to spend more on sustainable products. They care about environmental impact and claim they want brands that align with their values. Yet, when it comes to actual purchases, price, convenience, and practical utility dominate decision-making.
The Role of Sustainability in Decision-Making
Sustainability, while important, rarely acts as the primary driver of purchase intent. Instead, it functions as a differentiator – a reason to choose one brand over another – after other barriers such as price, quality, and trust have been addressed.
Zalando’s 2021 Attitude-Behaviour Gap report highlights this contradiction. While over 60% of consumers state that sustainability is important, only a fraction actively seek out information or allow it to influence their final purchase. Moreover, sustainability-focused brands often compound the problem by overemphasising their green credentials at the expense of addressing customers’ immediate needs.
The Problem with Leading with Sustainability
Sustainability-focused brands, often driven by passion for their mission, tend to prioritise their eco-credentials in their messaging. They dedicate valuable packaging space to green claims rather than customer benefits, and their social media is often dominated by “sustainability storytelling”.
While this approach engages values-driven supporters, it rarely converts them into buyers. Overemphasising sustainability too early in the purchase journey can alienate potential customers who are still evaluating price, quality, and practicality.
A New Hypothesis: Sustainability After the Sale
Our hypothesis is simple yet transformative:
- Top-of-Funnel (TOFU) messaging should focus on meeting the customer’s immediate needs, highlighting how the product solves their problems and aligns with their aspirations.
- Sustainability messaging is most effective in the post-purchase phase, where customers are already committed to the brand and are seeking validation for their decision.
This is the perfect time to create emotional resonance through storytelling about impact. When framed effectively, post-purchase sustainability messaging can even encourage word-of-mouth referrals by empowering customers to virtue signal their eco-conscious choice.
The Science Behind the Strategy
This approach leverages the Peak-End Rule, a behavioural principle that states people judge experiences not by their entirety but by two key moments:
- The Peak: The most emotionally intense part of the experience.
- The End: The final interaction, which leaves the most lasting impression.
In eCommerce, these moments can be deliberately engineered to create a positive emotional response. For sustainability-focused brands, the post-purchase period is an unparalleled opportunity to deliver these peaks and ends.
Why the Post-Purchase Phase Matters
After completing a purchase, customers experience a value gap. They’ve parted with their money (a tangible loss) but have yet to receive their product (the anticipated gain).
This moment is fertile ground for buyer’s remorse. Behavioural studies confirm that losses loom larger than gains in our minds – a phenomenon known as loss aversion. Without intervention, this gap can diminish the customer’s emotional satisfaction with their purchase.
For sustainability-focused brands, the post-purchase phase is a strategic moment to highlight eco-credentials, create an emotional peak, and reassure customers that their decision aligns with their values.
Implementing the Peak-End Rule in Sustainability Marketing
Here’s how sustainability brands can engineer emotional peaks and positive endings in the post-purchase phase:
- Celebrate Their Decision
The confirmation email is more than a receipt – it’s a chance to validate the customer’s choice and highlight its positive impact. Personalising these messages with tangible, per-purchase figures makes them more compelling and shareable: “Thanks to your purchase, 2kg of waste has been diverted from landfills!” - Sustain Anticipation
Use shipping updates to build excitement while emphasising sustainability. For example:“Your order is on its way—carefully packed in 100% recyclable materials to minimise waste.” - End on a High Note
The thank-you email is the final touchpoint, an opportunity to tell a compelling story about the customer’s impact:“You’ve made a difference! Your purchase has helped provide clean water access for a family for one month.”
By using the post-purchase phase to deliver emotional peaks and a positive ending, sustainability brands can ensure the customer remembers the experience favourably.
[Note: All sustainability claims must be evidenced and substantiated to comply with The Green Claims Code and maintain consumer trust]
Results: A Case Study
To test this framework, we worked with an ethical fashion brand to shift their sustainability messaging from TOFU to the post-purchase stage. The results were groundbreaking:
- Revenue Per Recipient: £2.52 from a post-purchase email flow traditionally not designed to generate revenue.
- Placed Order Rate: 2.86%, increasing lifetime value and reducing the time between initial purchase and repurchase.
- Customer Loyalty: Returning customer rate increased by 6%.
- Focusing on customer centric messaging at top-of-funnel increased annual sales by 53%
These results demonstrate the power of aligning sustainability messaging with the post-purchase phase, turning a potential moment of buyer’s remorse into one of pride and advocacy.
Why This Strategy Works
This approach aligns with key behavioural science principles:
- The Peak-End Rule ensures customers leave the journey with a strong, positive impression.
- Loss Aversion is mitigated by creating emotional reassurance during the value gap.
- Cognitive Dissonance is reduced when customers are given reasons to feel good about their choice.
Implications for Sustainability Marketing
This research suggests a paradigm shift for sustainability-focused product brands: stop leading with eco-credentials and instead use them strategically to enhance the emotional impact of the purchase journey.
Key Takeaways
- Top-of-Funnel Messaging: Focus on the customer’s needs, aspirations, and practical concerns.
- Post-Purchase Strategy: Leverage the Peak-End Rule to turn sustainability into a loyalty driver.
- Shift the Narrative: Sustainability sells when it’s presented as a reason to feel proud after the purchase, not as the primary justification for buying.
For brands struggling to close the attitude-behaviour gap, this strategy provides a science-backed solution.
By rethinking when and how you tell your sustainability story, you can turn sustainability-focused products into mass-market favourites—and prove that sustainability can sell.
Get our latest behavioural insights straight to your inbox: